The FEI Tribunal recently handed US eventer Andrew McConnon a 20-month suspension, rather than the lifetime ban sought by the FEI, due to insufficient and weak evidence of horse abuse. The 120-page decision highlighted problems with photographic and video evidence and gave limited weight to most witness testimonies. McConnon was found guilty of mid-range abuse on three occasions in early 2024, but the tribunal accepted his explanations for some actions and noted his remorse and mitigating personal circumstances. The tribunal emphasized the need for robust proof in serious abuse cases and proportional sanctions, ultimately concluding that the allegations did not warrant the harshest penalties.

The case involved multiple witnesses alleging a pattern of abuse over several years, including excessive whipping, kicking, and neglect, but many claims lacked corroboration or were undermined by inconsistencies and the inability to cross-examine key witnesses. Some witnesses described a culture of fear and lack of accountability around McConnon, while others noted his occasional good behavior. The FEI took over the investigation after USEF declined due to jurisdictional limits. The tribunal criticized FEI Legal for overstating evidence and stressed that equestrian sport must uphold horse welfare, but sanctions must be based on clear, convincing proof.