In a disturbing case of animal cruelty in San Joaquin County, California, two women, Jan Johnson and Justine Fitzhenry, were arrested following a months-long investigation that revealed severe neglect of horses. Authorities discovered 27 dead horses and numerous malnourished animals during a warrant search of multiple properties in Clements on January 22, 2025. Johnson faces over 20 felony counts, including animal cruelty and illegal firearm possession, while Fitzhenry is charged with three felony counts of animal cruelty.
The investigation, which began in August 2024, uncovered additional horrors, including 53 more dead horses, a dead dog, and a cow on other properties. Many of the surviving horses were in critical condition, requiring immediate medical attention, and 16 were rescued and placed in the care of a nonprofit organization. The Sheriff’s Office also found a cockfighting ring on Johnson’s property, further complicating the case.
Sheriff Patrick Withrow emphasized the importance of a thorough investigation to ensure justice for the animals involved. Both women are scheduled for arraignment on June 6, with Johnson potentially facing up to 25 years in prison if convicted. The case has drawn significant attention, highlighting the need for accountability in animal welfare.
