New York City’s City Council has rejected Ryder’s Law, proposed legislation aimed at phasing out the city’s historic horse-drawn carriage industry by halting new licenses and replacing carriages with electric vehicles. The bill’s defeat sparked criticism from supporters who argue the industry is outdated and harmful to horses, citing public safety concerns and animal welfare issues. Animal rights groups and a majority of New Yorkers reportedly favor ending the carriage trade, while the Transport Workers Union representing carriage drivers suggested compromises such as relocating stables to Central Park to address critics’ concerns.

Despite the setback, outgoing Mayor Eric Adams and Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani have expressed support for stronger regulation or outright bans on horse-drawn carriages, highlighting ongoing debates about public safety and animal welfare. Adams has already issued an executive order to increase industry oversight. The controversy reflects broader tensions between preserving tradition, public opinion, and evolving urban policies in New York City.