The Eclipse Awards finalists for 2025 will be announced on January 4, with the awards dinner scheduled for January 22 in Palm Beach, Florida. The article critiques the nomination process, noting the sometimes arbitrary nature of having only three finalists per category and the drama built around the ceremony to mimic the Academy Awards. Hall of Fame jockey Jerry Bailey, who recently resumed voting after rejoining the National Turf Writers and Broadcasters, shares his perspective on judging horses and jockeys. He emphasizes the importance of Grade 1 race performances, overall body of work, and head-to-head competition, while also expressing a strict stance on eligibility, particularly regarding foreign horses with limited North American starts.
Bailey discusses specific contenders, such as Bentornato for male sprinter despite a short campaign, and Sovereignty for Horse of the Year despite missing the Preakness due to illness. He also highlights the close competition between jockeys Flavien Prat and Irad Ortiz, ultimately favoring Prat for his Grade 1 wins and win percentage. Bailey’s insights reflect a nuanced approach to the awards, balancing statistical achievements with the quality and significance of performances throughout the racing season.
