The Department of Justice’s efforts to reassure the public about the welfare of Bailey, a dog introduced as a “comfort dog” at Magilligan Prison, have failed to quell growing concerns. Animal welfare advocates, led by Tara Cunningham of Causeway Dog Rescue, have criticized the lack of transparency and safeguards surrounding Bailey’s care, highlighting that he was placed in a high-security block housing violent offenders and is under the care of a violent sex offender. Questions remain about Bailey’s training, ownership, and the unclear sourcing of both Bailey and a second dog introduced to the prison, with some local rescue organizations reportedly declining to supply dogs to the prison.

Cunningham emphasized that Northern Ireland’s animal welfare legislation lacks definitions and standards for therapy or emotional support dogs, leaving animals like Bailey vulnerable. Despite a local council inspection stating Bailey is well cared for, concerns persist over inadequate oversight, unclear responsibilities for his welfare, and the absence of a clear plan for his future. Causeway Dog Rescue is calling for a full independent investigation, greater transparency, and a review of policies regarding animals in prisons, demanding that Bailey be removed from the prison environment and properly rehomed.