Six months after returning from a suspension related to horse welfare concerns, Olympic dressage champion Charlotte Dujardin has again faced criticism over her treatment of horses following a video filmed at the Amsterdam World Cup. Experts, including former European equine vets and leading welfare scientists, have condemned the footage showing Dujardin using spurs while holding a tight rein on the mare Alive And Kicking, causing conflicting signals that put the horse under significant stress and behavioral conflict. This riding style contradicts modern dressage principles emphasizing harmony and clear communication between horse and rider, with welfare organizations calling for better recognition and enforcement of acceptable riding practices.

Despite the backlash and calls for mandatory rehabilitation for riders returning from suspension, Dujardin has not publicly addressed the new concerns, referring inquiries to the British Equestrian Federation (BEF), which has not clarified its stance on the matter. Critics argue that the BEF’s quick reinstatement of Dujardin without a rehabilitation period raises questions about the prioritization of horse welfare. The controversy highlights ongoing tensions in equestrian sport between competitive pressures and ethical treatment of horses, with experts urging reforms to ensure horses’ well-being is never compromised for performance.